Sahl ibn Ziyad’s Weaknesses and Validations in the Scale of Arbitration

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Associate Professor, Department of Islamic theology, Allameh Tabataba'i University, Tehran, Iran (Corresponding Author)

2 Fourth Level Student, Imam Hassan Mojtaba Higher Education Institute, Iran

3 Professor, Department of Islamic Studies, Allameh Tabataba'i University, Tehran, Iran

Abstract

Introduction
Sahl ibn Ziyad Adami, nicknamed Razi, is one of the transmitters of many Shia hadiths. This transmitter has understood the presence of Imam Javad, Imam Hadi, and Imam Hasan Asgari (pbuh). Many traditions have been narrated from this transmitter; for example, Kuleini narrated more than 150 cases directly from Sahl ibn Ziyad in his Kafi book. However, there is a difference of opinion regarding their reliability and lack of reliability. The importance of this study shows that despite the fact that Sahl ibn Ziyad is one of the transmitters of many hadiths and many hadiths have been narrated from him in Kāfī book, most of the jurists have weakened Sahl ibn Ziyad and do not trust his hadiths before Muhaqiq Behbahani.
However, Muhaqiq Bihbahani in his "ta'liqat on Manhaj al-Maqal", p. 176 and the book of Masabih al-Zilam, vol. 2, p. 496, seeks to prove the reliability of Sahl ibn Ziyad. After Muhaqiq Behbahani, many researchers have believed in his reliability or at least the validity of his traditions. The question is, what is the basis of weakening Sahl ibn Ziyad? Are these weaknesses true about him? Are the validations made about Sahl ibn Ziyad defensible? The importance of this study is that proving the reliability of Sahl ibn Ziyad or lack of it will have an important impact on the field of Shia religious and jurisprudential education.
Methodology
In order to achieve this goal, a Isnad and a descriptive and analytical method, and in some cases, a comparative method have been used. Following the views of Rijal books such as Rijāl Ghada'iri, Rijāl Shaykh Tusi, Rijāl Najashi, Rijāl Kashshī, and... we carefully examined the different views about Sahl ibn Ziyad and by comparing them, we explained the basis of the viewpoint of validating and weakening of Sahl ibn Ziyad and the reason for his weaknesses.
Results and Discussion
By following the words of thinkers and the books of Rijali, we concluded that if we understand the reasons for the weakening of Sahl ibn Ziyad in the words of some great ones such as Kashshī, Ibn Walid, Shaykh Tusi, Ghada'iri, and Najashi, then we can explain their words. For example, Najashi in this sentence: "Kan Zaifa fi Hadith..." (He was very weak in hadith) did not consider Sahl ibn Ziyad to be weak, but attributed the weakness to his hadiths, which shows that he does not accept his method of narrating hadiths, and the phrase «غیر معتمد فیه» (He is unreliable) also indicates the unreliability of Sahl ibn Ziyad in hadiths. Many researchers have come to the phrase «ضعیف فی الحدیث» (weak in hadith) to refer to weakness and trust in messengers. For example, Sahib Jawahar says that Najashi said about Sahl that he is weak in hadith, and Ibn Ghada'iri also said that he narrates weak hadith and relies on the traditions of the messengers. These words do not contradict the validation of Sheikh Tusi and Allameh, because these taunts are about his traditions and not Sahl ibn Ziyad himself. It seems that if the bases of validating and weakening are explained correctly, proving the reliability of Sahl is not a difficult task. The main reason for not attesting to Sahl is his weakening by Ahmad ibn Muhammad ibn Isa Ash'ari, which is a reflection of Qomiein's strict view on "extremism" (Ghuluww); but this view has no scientific basis and is not accepted and confirmed by all the scholars of jurists. Therefore, the weakening that is based on it is also not accepted. In addition, there is much evidence on the reliability of Sahl, the most important of which are: the abundance of traditions about Sahl in important books such as Kafi, the abundance of quotes from great figures, the validation of Sahl ibn Ziyad and his reliability by the contemporary scholars such as Imam Khumeini (ra), Ayatullah Araki, Ayatullah Shubairi Zanjani, and Ayatullah Sobhani. Therefore, despite the accusations and weaknesses that have been made about Sahl, considering the much evidence on his reliability Sahl ibn Ziyad can be considered reliable and his traditions can be trusted, and because of the existence of Sahl ibn Ziyad in the document of a tradition, that tradition cannot be considered invalid.
Conclusion
By following the words of intellectuals and the books of Rijali, I reached the fact that the important reason for weakening Sahl ibn Ziyad Adami by the early scholars is the reflection of their strict view and narrow definition of "extremism" (Ghuluww), but the later scholars had a more extensive definition and different opinions about Ghuluww. Therefore, they defended the reliability of Sahl ibn Ziyad and considered him trustworthy, and accepted the traditions narrated by Sahl ibn Ziyad. Thus, based on the strictness of his predecessors, he is considered a hypocrite, but based on the extended definition of his early and later scholars, he is reliable. This research considers the second point of view to be fairer according to the investigation and it cannot be considered invalid just because of the existence of Sahl in the narrative document.

Keywords

References

Refrences
The Holy Quran.
Amelī (Shahid Sanī), Zain al-Din ibn Ali ibn Ahmed Zain al-Din (2000), Rasail al-Shahid al-(Reza Mokhtarī and Hossein Shafiei, researcher and proofreader) Qom: Office of Islamic Propaganda of Qom Seminary. [In Arabic]
----------------- (2001) Ruz al-Jinan fi Sharh Irshad al-Azhan. Qom: Bustan Ketab Institute. [In Arabic]
----------------- (1992) Masalak al-Afham. (Research group of the Institute of Islamic Education, researcher and proofreader) Qom: Islamic Encyclopaedia Institute. [In Arabic]
Arāki, Mohammad Ali (2000). Kitab Al-Salat. Qom: Office of Ayatullah Araki. [In Arabic]
---------------- (1995) Kitab Al-Taharah. Qom: Dar Rah-e Haq Institute. [In Arabic]
Ansārī, Mortezā (1994). Kitab Al-Taharah. First edition. Research Group of the Congress. Qom: World Congress of Commemoration of Sheikh Azam Ansari. [In Arabic]
---------------- (1994), Kitab al-Salah. (Congress Research Group, Proofreading Researcher) Qom: World Congress in honor of Sheikh Azam Ansari, first edition. [In Arabic]
Ardabīlī (Muqadas Ardabili), Ahmed ibn Muhammad (N.D.). Mojtaba Araqi, researcher. Qom: Islamic Publishing House. [In Arabic]
Behbahānī, Mohammad Bagher ibn Akmal. (2003). Hashiatah Majma’ Al-Fedath va Burhan. Qom: Allameh Mujaddid Vahid Behbahani Institute. [In Arabic]
----------------- (N.D.) Al-Taliqah Ala Manhaj al-Maqal. Chap-e Sangi. [In Arabic]
----------------- (1981) Masabih al-Usbam in the description of Mofatih al-Sharia. Qom: Allameh Mujaddid Vahid Behbahani Institute. [In Arabic]
Bahrul Uloom, Seyyed Mehdi. (1984). Favaed Al-Rajalah. Tehran: Al-Sadegh School. [In Arabic]
Hāerī Mazandaranī, Sheikh Muhammad ibn Ismail (1995), Mantah al-Maqal fi ahwal al-Rajal. (Al Al-Bait research group, researcher and proofreader). Qom: Al Al-Bait Institute. [In Arabic]
Hosseinī, Seyyed Muhammad ibn Muhammad Mīrdamad (2001) Al-Rawasheh al-Samawiyyah fi Sharh al-Ahadith Al-Amamiya. (Gholam Hossein Qeysariha and Ne’matullah Jalili, researcher), Qom: Dar al-Hadith for printing and publishing. [In Arabic]
Hallī, Jamal al-Din Ahmed ibn Muhammad Asadi (1986), Al-Muhazab al-Bara' fi Sharh al-Mukhtasar al-Nafi’. Mojtaba Araqi, researcher and corrector. Qom: Islamic Publications Office affiliated with the Qom University College Teachers Society. [In Arabic]
Hallī, Hasan ibn Youssef ibn Motahar Asadī, (N.D.), The Book of Fiqha. (Research Group of Al Al-Bayt Institute, Researcher and Corrector), Qom: Ahl Al-Bayt Institute. [In Arabic]
---------------- (1992) Various Shi'a in Al-Ahkam Al-Sharia. (Research Group of the Islamic Publications Office, Researcher and Corrector). [In Arabic]
---------------- (1991) Montahi al-Matlab fi Tahqiq Al-Mazhab. (jurisprudence section in the Islamic research community, researcher and proofreader). Mashhad: Islamic Research Council. [In Arabic]
Hallī, Muhaqiq Najm al-Din Jafar ibn Hasan, (1992) Al-Rasal al-Tsa'a. (Reza Ostadi, researcher and proofreader) Qom: Ayatullah Marashi Najafi Library. [In Arabic]
--------------- (1986) Al-Motabar fi Sharh al-Mūkhatsar. Qom: Sayyed al-Shohada Institute. [In Arabic]
--------------- (1991) Al-Nayah va Nokteha (Nokatah Al-Nahayah). (Islamic Publications Office Research Group, Researcher and Corrector) Qom: Islamic Publications Office affiliated with the Qom Theological Seminary Teachers Society. [In Arabic]
Fāzel Abi, Hassan ibn Abi Talib Yousefi, (1996) Discovering the Symbols in a Short Description of the Benefits. (Ali Panah Eshtehardi, Agha Hossein Yazdi, Researcher and Proofreader) Qom: Islamic Publications Office attached to the Qom Seminary Teachers Society. [In Arabic]
Fāzel Lankaranī, Muhammad (2010). Explanation of the Shari'ah in the book of Tahrir al-Wasila. Vol. 1. Qom: Jurisprudential Center of Infallible Imams (PBUT). [In Arabic]
Hallī (Fakhr al-Muhaqeqin), Abu Talib Muhammad ibn Hasan, (2008) Explanation of the Benefits in the Explanation of the Problems of the Rules, Qom: Esmaeilian. [In Arabic]
Hor Amolī, Muhammad ibn Al-Hassan, (1981) Wasael al-Shia. 6th edition, Tehran: Maktabah al-Islamiya. [In Arabic]
Hallī, Yahya ibn Saeed (2007). Nazh al-Nazir. (Nur al-Din Vaezi, researcher and proofreader). Najaf: Al-Adab Press. [In Arabic]
Ibn Ghazaeri, Ahmad ibn Hossein. (2001). Rijal Ibn Ghazaeri. (Seyed Mohammad Reza Hosseini Jalali, researcher). Qom: Dar al-Hadith. [In Arabic]
Ibn Qolwieh, Jafar ibn Muhammad. (2019). Kamel Al-Ziyarat. Najaf: Dar al-Mortazawieh. [In Arabic]
Khomeinī, Seyyed Ruhollah Mousavi, (N.D.) Ketab al-Tahara. (new edition). Tehran: Institute for Organizing and Publishing Imam Khomeini's Works. [In Arabic]
Khoei, Seyyed Abulqasem Mousavi, (N.D.) Mo’jam Rijal al-Hadith va Tafsil Tabaqat Al-Rawat. Qom: Shia Works Publishing Center. [In Arabic]
-------------- (2000) Encyclopaedia of Imam Al-Khoei. (Mortaza Boroujerdi, Moqarar) Qom: Institute for Revival of Imam Al-Khoei's Works, 3rd edition. [In Arabic]
Koleinī, Abu Jafar Muhammad ibn Yaqub, (1986). Al-Kafi. vol. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, Tehran: Dar al-Katb al-Islamiyya. [In Arabic]
Keshī, Abu Amr Muhammad ibn Omar ibn Abdul Aziz, (1988) Akhtar al-Marifa al-Rijal (Rījal al-Kashī). (Hasan Mostafavī, researcher and proofreader) Mashhad: Mashhad University Publishing House. [In Arabic]
Mamqānī, Abdullah, (1990) Meqbas al-Hedayah fi Elm Al-Daraya. (Mohammed Reza Mamqani, researcher) Qom: Al Al-Bayt al-Ehya al-Toras Institute. [In Arabic]
-------------- (1937) Ghaya al-Amal fi Sharh al-Makasab. Qom: Majma’a al-Zakhayer Al-Islamiyya. [In Arabic]
Majlesī I, Mohammad Taqi, (2019) Al-Mutaqeen University. (Seyed Hossein Mousavi Kermani and Ali Panah Eshtehardi, researcher) Qom: Kushanpour Foundation. [In Arabic]
-------------- (1993) Lavame’ Sahibqarani, Qom: Ismailian Institute, Edition 2. [In Arabic]
Majlisī II, Mohammad Baqer, (2008) Al-Wajizeh Fi al-Rajal. (Mohammed Kazem Rahman Setayesh, Researcher) Tehran: Allameh Majlisi Commemoration Conference. [In Arabic]
Masjidī, Haydar Abdul Karim, (2016) Essay on the personality of Sahl ibn Ziyad and tradition. Qom: Dar al-Hadith. [In Arabic]
Mahdavī, Hassan, (2012) Sahl ibn Ziyad in the mirror of the science of men. Qom: Jurisprudential Center of Infallible Imams (peace be upon them). [In Persian]
------------- (2016) Researching the personality of Sahl ibn Ziyad, Qom: Ahl al-Bayt Jurisprudence Magazine, No. 88. [In Arabic]
Mohammadī (Ray Shahrī), Mohammad (2014). Foreign course on Hajj jurisprudence: the subject of the status of men of Sahl ibn Ziyad. Official website of Mohammadi Ray Shahri. [In Persian]
Muhaqiq Dāmād, Muhammad (2002). Book of Hajj. Qom: Isra Publishing House. [In Arabic]
Najashī, Abu Al-Hassan Ahmad ibn Ali ibn Ahmad, (1986) List of Names of Al-Shi'a Authors (Rajal al-Najashi), (Seyed Musa Shubairi Zanjani, Researcher and Proofreader) Qom: Islamic Publications Office affiliated with the Qom Theological Seminary Society. [In Arabic]
Najafi, Muhammad Hassan ibn Baqir, (N.D.) Jawaharl al-Kalam, (Abbas Quchani, researcher and proofreader) Beirut: Dar Ihya Al-Trath al-Arabi, 7th edition. [In Arabic]
Narāghī, Abu al-Qasim, (2001) Shab al-Maqal fi jirah al-Rijal, T (Mohsen Ahmadi, Researcher), Qom, Allameh Naraghi Honoring Congress, second edition. [In Arabic]
Qomī, Ibn Qolouyeh, Abu al-Qasim Jafar ibn Muhammad ibn Jafar (2019). Kamele al-Ziyaratat. Najaf: Dar al-Mortazawieh. [In Arabic]
Qomī, Ali ibn Ibrahim ibn Hashem (1983). Qomī's commentary. Qom: Dar al-Kitab Institute, third edition. [In Arabic]
Sobhāni, Jafar, (1998) Koliat fi Elm al-Rijal. Qom: Qom Seminary Management Center. [In Arabic]
----------- (2003). Principles of hadith and rulings. Qom: Institute of Imam Sadīq, PBUH. [In Arabic]
Sajjadī Amīn, Mehdī, (2015) Father's permission in the marriage of a virgin girl. Qom, Women and Family Research Center. [In Persian]
Shubairi Zanjānī, Mūsā, (2003), Nikah Book. Qom: Rai Pardaz Research Institute. [In Persian]
Sadouq, Muhammad ibn Ali ibn Baboyeh (2019). Al-Tawheed. Qom: Jamia Modaresin Publications, second edition. [In Arabic]
Tostarī, Mohammad Taqi. (1996). Qamous Al-Rījal. Edition 2. Qom: Islamic publishing institute affiliated with Qom teachers community. [In Arabic]
Tostarī, Asadullah (N.D.) Comparison of Al-Anwar and Nafais al-Asrar. Qom: Al-Bayt Institute. [In Arabic]
Torabī Shahrezaei, Akbar (2008). A study in the science of men. Qom: Osveh. [In Persian]
Tabasī, Muhammad Jafar (2011). Sahl ibn Ziyad between trust and weakness. Syrian edition: Publication of the Jurisprudential Center of Infallible Imams, peace be upon them. [In Arabic]
Tūsī, Abu Jafar Muhammad ibn Hassan, (2011) Al-Istbasar Fima Akhtulf Man Al-Akhbar. Tehran: Dar al-Ketab Islami. [In Arabic]
------------ (1994) Al-Rajal. (Javad Qayoumi Esfahani, researcher) Qom: Islamic publishing institute affiliated with the community of teachers. [In Arabic]
------------ (1999) Al-Fahrest. (Sayed Abdulaziz Tabatabayi, researcher) Qom: Mohagheg Tabatabayi Library. [In Arabic]
------------ (2008) Tahzeeb al-Ahkam. Tehran: Dar al-Kutub al-Islamiyya. [In Arabic]
------------ (1998) Astabsar. (Seyed Hassan Mousavi Khorsan, researcher). Qom: Dar al-Katb al-Islamiya. [In Arabic]
Hadith Research
Volume 15, Issue 2 - Serial Number 30
30
December 2023
Pages 271-302

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics